Nov 29, 2008
U.S. Shliach Spoke to Terrorist

EXCLUSIVE: A Lubavitch official in the U.S. had spoken with one of the Indian gunman who was holding hostages at the Chabad House in Mumbai, COLlive has learned. FBI and other negotiation experts in Israel were guiding him through the process which included six phone calls. "Please help, immediately, please," a woman's voice was heard.

By Yehuda Ceitlin, Editor of COLlive

A Lubavitch official in the U.S. apparently made unintentional contact with one of the alleged gunmen holding hostages at the Chabad House in Mumbai, India, COLlive has learned.

In trying desperately reaching his colleague Chabad Rabbi Gavriel Holtzberg, the phone was finally answered but not by the rabbi or his wife Rivka who were held captive in Nariman House, the five-story building where the Rohr Chabad Lubavitch Center was situated.

Sources suggested that the official was Rabbi Levi Shemtov, Shliach in DC and Washington Director of American Friends of Lubavitch.

Rabbi Holtzberg was last heard from on Wednesday when he telephoned the Israeli Consulate in Mumbai, saying in Hebrew, "The situation is not good." The line then went dead.

While Shemtov declined to comment to COLlive about the matter, someone with knowledge of what transpired told of the following:

It appears that the alleged gunman was in reach of the mobile phone of Gabi Holtzberg.

The official (Shemtov) called it on Thursday night and was answered with a gruff "Hallo."

"Who is this?" the man asked.

"I'm a friend of some of the people you're with," the official reportedly answered.

The voice requested someone who spoke Urdu, an Indo-Aryan language.


The Lubavitch official immediately moved to activate contacts in the situation room in the White House, the Indian Ambassador to Washington, DC, and the Israeli Foreign Ministry officials in Jerusalem and Washington, DC.

During this process, the official also began receiving assistance from negotiations experts in Israel and the U.S.

(FBI agents later arrived at Lubavitch World Headquarters at 770 Eastern Parkway in Brooklyn, NY, to interview the Indian-speaking translator who got on the line to mediate between the two.)

It remains unclear if the Holtzbergs were alive at the time of the calls. Although the number was public on the internet and is known to many Israeli backpackers, employees at 770 asked journalists, including COLlive, not to call Holtzberg's mobile so as not to interrupt the communications.

During the second call, the gunman demanded to speak with a representative of the Indian government "within one hour."

The official demanded to speak to one of the captives. "Please help, immediately, please," a woman's voice was heard in an Israeli accent.


Someone then tried to contact an official of India's police department. An attempt to reach the deputy head of the Indian anti-terror task force (the head was killed that day) succeeded, but the line was interrupted.

Getting the gunman on the line again, the Indian police officer was conferenced in but couldn't be heard by the terrorist. This was due to what appeared to be a technical problem, a source explained.

Trying to engage the gunman and at the advice of professionals, the official asked him at another phone call for his name and if he wanted something, like food.

The man gave a name (the same one he later used with a local TV station) and added "we didn't come to eat. We came to do our mission."

The communication soon stopped altogether, presumably because the battery had finally run out on the cell phone.

Upon arriving at the site of the massacre, members of ZAKA disaster victim identification force found the bodies of the rabbi and his wife.

"When we entered the Chabad House, we saw a home completely ruined by hand grenades," Shuki Brif of ZAKA said. "It was a shocking sight. Prayer books and many other objects were all over the place. The body of the rabbi's wife was draped in a prayer shawl. We estimate that she died earlier, and the rabbi covered her."

Can't watch?
click here (for download)

Most Read Most Comments

Opinions and Comments
This is chilling
I cant believe he actually spoke with them.
(11/30/2008 12:24:54 AM)
He covered his wifes holy body with a Talis!
What Hell it must have been.

Hashem Yerachem!

(11/30/2008 12:54:54 AM)
Oy hashem!
Why did they deserve this? why did all the attempts fail?!
(11/30/2008 12:57:59 AM)
Hashem yishmor!!
They are animals! no mercy whatsoever. They should burn in hell.
(11/30/2008 2:18:03 AM)
If this is the same Holtzberg - he was a classmate of Ari Halbershtam HY"D always taken by a terrorist bullet on the famous attack on the Brooklyn Bridge in '94. I taught them both back in 1990.
(11/30/2008 7:23:25 AM)
age is wrong
holtzberg was 29, ari would be 31
(11/30/2008 10:23:01 AM)
There are 3 Holtzberg families in crown heights
some of thier children have the same names since they were named after the same person
(11/30/2008 12:25:11 PM)
wow, i cant beleive he had to go through covering his wife witha tallis what he must have gone thru is UNIMAGINABLE!!!
(11/30/2008 2:25:16 PM)
What's Your Opinion? Post a Comment

Your Comment:

Comments must be approved before being published. Thank You!

Make COLiveŽ your homepage | Contact Us
© 2019