Question to COLlive for Mrs. Sarah Junik:
While in most cases I agree with the above argument, maybe the Lubavitch Shidduch System is not for everyone.
Allow me to explain:
Take your average 770 Bocher. He hopefully has not had much contact with girls and the concept of sitting and talking with a girl and her giving him her undivided attention, is all new and very exciting for him. So in many cases he can rather easily “fall in love” with the girl (and her with him.)
But for a guy who’s a little more “chilled” who has had contact with girls over the years. That element of excitement is not really there.
The process sort of goes like this: you’re mother gets a call from a shadchin about a girl whom the Shadchin really doesn’t know. She looks into it and gets all the generic answers. You agree to go out, you go on a date and you think to yourself “nice girl, but why is she different than anyone else out there? What makes her the special one for me?”
At this point you can do one of two things: you can end it right there and keep on looking for the one who sweeps you off your feet, or you can commit to go out for a while (as is done in less religious circles), to see if any feelings develop and if you really are compatible with her.
In other words, in my opinion most any two people from similar backgrounds and with similar outlooks can get married and lead happy lives together. And the LSS takes advantage (in a good way) of the lack of cross gender exposure to bring together guys and girls, but maybe if you haven’t fully lived the Lubavitch lifestyle the LSS won’t work for you.
(I’m not saying 770 guys don’t have the same challenges but it’s not as pronounced and widespread)
Mrs. Junik’s Response
In order to answer your question properly let me define the LSS as you call it.
The first step starts with the determination, either by the parents or by the individual that they are ready for marriage.
I am not going to go in details about the stages, it would take too long, if interested check out the blog: shidduchim101.blogspot.com which does go into details.
Step 2- have a round table conversation about the qualities one brings to a marriage and the qualities that one looks for in a spouse that would complement or enhance one’s own.
Step 3- make a list with at the most 7 necessary qualities – if 3 are met, you are in good shape.
Step 4a – Shidduchim come from the Eibishter. Therefore, make yourself a keily for the brocha you are asking for. Daven, give tzedokah, etc.
Step 4- Time for the parents to talk to friends, family, neighbors and shadchonim. Let us not forget the new sources such as chabadmatch.com. (look on the blog about how to make it most effective) Please note: shadchonim are not the only ones that one should talk to about being “in the parsha”, in fact most shidduchim come about from family and friends, those shidduchim are still within the LSS. Do not think that because a shadchan did not make the shidduch this is not part of the system. The bocher or meidel should also ask their married friends to think of the right person for him/her, giving them the information from the list (step2).
Therefore, even if you are not a 770 bocher, even if you met your future wife at a party, if the parents (or mashpia or married friend, or anyone who will help you out) look into the background and character of your future mate and compare it to your qualities and shortcomings and they find a match, that is when shidduch dating will bring results and will save said bocher a lot of agmas nefesh.
Step 5 – When a name comes up, do your research. Be thorough, not obsessive.
Step 6 – Only when parents are satisfied with the research should the young man or lady go out. “Generic answers” do not count. When the parents is ready to make a lechaim based on their research, that is when the young man/lady should be told about it and a shidduch date set up . Shidduch dating is not a pastime; a lot of agonizing and reflection goes into it. Let the couple go out only when it is reasonably sure it will work out.
If Step 2 was done correctly then the offers will be within the ballpark we are looking for and the shidduch dates will be within the possible matches.
Step 7 – Shidduch dating. I cannot do justice to the subject here but suffice it to say that some people can decide sooner, whiles for some it will take longer, if someone for example had a broken engagement they will need more time. Just consider that no matter how many times one goes out, one will never know the other person totally, therefore the purpose of the going out is to see if there is a connection between the two and if the little irritants we all have are acceptable to the other person. Read Eternal Joy or Shidduchim U’nissuin.
Step 8 – one is not out of the woods even after the engagement, therefore limit the amount of times the couple goes out and speaks.
Now to reply to your comment, it makes no difference to the LSS if you are “chilled” frozen or cooked all the way!
If you are a bocher that has had no exposure to girls (what, no sisters?) and you are lucky enough to marry the first girl you go out with, you will have certain advantages in your connection to your wife that others who have had a more worldly outlook will not have. But the method of finding a wife is not different. Sure the chilled bocher will look for a different kind of girl to begin with, but the method of finding that girl is the same.
It is not well done to sneer at that 770 bocher and say it is easy for him to “fall in love”. No one should FALL, in love or in anything else; and “sweeps you off your feet” has the same effect of dumping you on the floor! A couple who has reached a decision to marry has hopefully done so because they have found the right combination of character and are comfortable and probably have a crush on one another. Real Love comes after marriage. This is true with the chilled bocher as well.
Answer : Go out again until your sure either way (or until you get dumped). Also take the time to think between dates ie try to spread them apart. Think with you mind not only with your hart. Look for someone normal later you will see the greateness as you give to each other. Ask experts and loved ones.
B’Hatzlocha,
Married 13 years and growing
how is it that i have it all wrong?
explain yourself.
it takes one to know one
and in that case you should try to help
these guys instead of knocking them
girls have to get a grip?? oh my !! you have it all wrong!
#14 wrote
I am your average 770 bocher, considered a good bocher etc. from a good family and everythihg.
still I expect to be excited about my future wife, i am totally expecting it to be everything that i imagined and not a bit less.
i wont settle for what sounds good on paper.
and youre blaming the girls??
how do u know that #16 was screaming??
your comment is so wrong on many different levels…possibly the intertwining of that phrase and it’s connotations, followed by the yiddish phrase…but i like it..:)
and yes so true. and girls have got to get a grip..
in most cases “derech ho-ish, lachazor achar ho-isha” vdal
btw
the boys know that they are playing on the girls weaknesses
the girls often believe that the words are proof of REAL genuine love concern etc! they fool themselves out of desperation! nebach nebach!
it takes two to tango, farshtaist?
there are wayyyy to many nutcrackers out there like u, who wont settle for a drop less! Go live in utopia – where your dream princess kallah is waiting!!!
you are definitely not an average 770- bochur!
the average bochur has a lot more sechel than you!! and if ch’v you are then im really scared to meet the underaveraged type of guy!
i agree with #40
you must have come in to contact with the wrong guys
because not all of them out there are as bad as you make them seem
just remember to recognize your needs as much as theirs
and you will come to see that
the girls are to blame just as much as the men involved.
and im talking from experience
oh, and im a girl
shocker!
Why does “contact with girls” mean to you “sweet talking jerk”?
“uses the internet (albeit mainly for Kodesh only – keeping in contact with Shlichus year, and so on)”
Can’t be both dude… its either mainly for Kodesh or only for Kodesh!
you hit it right on the nail!
the damage these girls suffer bec of these sweet-talkers is feeling degraded and tricked, as well as haunting guilt and regret!
especially how such cheep thrills impact the pure love and clossesness with their own husband in the future!
a life long sentance of marital disconnect, all bec of spending her purity and intimacy prematurely,
instead of letting it build and compound when saved for a first love in marriage!!
so considering the selfishness and resulting damage, the “OUTRAGE” is well placed!
give me a break,
girls have just as much of a desire as the guy does
and we are not! thier prey
we choose to get ourselves into it and therefore we get hurt
take responsibility for your actions,
– from a girl who has been around the block
this is soo true!!
to #16 – Takes one to know one…
Where do you get this idea that what the author is talking about is wrong and that “it’s against what G-d wants” G-d did not say though shalt not talk to girls. Please do not preach that what is a chumrah or a minhag etc (I know y’all might differ with that) is what G-d Said.
Yaakov Avinu and Moshe Rabeinu both met their wives on their own and did not have a Shadchan if what they did was against G-d then we got a problem with your Religion.
Please don’t scream at us, it’s is very bad manors. It also makes us not want to hear what you have to say. Also, you are making outrageous claims to think that someone who has had social contact with other human beings has “TAKEN ADVANTAGE OF ,DEGRADED AND WOMANIZED” (your sound like a shadchan I know in the Midwest)… You might live in a bubble but many of us live in the real world that is approximately 50% of the opposite gender and therefore unless you choose a lifestyle that completely isolates you from the opposite gender (as in extremely… Read more »
you are both assuming way too much
you are making filth of something that was not that
even though it is NOT the way
it is not like what you think
note: you see who you are – what are your deep dark thoughts – get to know yourself a little – may surprise yourselves.
to the person who said why is a 770 bochur on line?
naive – who cannot be on line in today’s world – wake up
I think you’ve got. it! 99,99% of the world has got it all wrong. A yasha koicach is forthcoming for transforming the most exciting part of a young persons life into one of fear, apprenhesion and doubt.
Isn’t #16 being rather harsh? Not all people who are ‘chilled’ are bad people who purposely and spitefully ruin all love-desperate girls. I think a little reality check would be helpful.
Just a check into reality, if you don’t think that EVERY 770 Bochur has e-mail, and uses the internet (albeit mainly for Kodesh only – keeping in contact with Shlichus year, and so on) you MUST check into this reality fast you are gonna be in for a real surprise…!
A 770 Bochur! (and “considered” a very good one at that!)
why????? WHY?!?!?
Why is it important to start goin on and on with the names? BH someone spoke up…now you have to make them feel like…?!?
took the words out of my mouth
This Article Just Clearly Showed Me – What kind of Lubavitchers Read this “stuff”. Ones who live in a completely different reality than I do and the Lubavitchers I know. Close minded much?
Glad it works for Y’all though.
But seriously — what makes The author and expert????
I think the term chilled has to be clarified a bit in this article. There are definitely different levels of “chilled” in Lubavitch. It is a very relative term. That is why when someone tells you the guy is chilled you have to ask what that means. Does he pick or trim his beard, does he listen to non-jewish music etc…. If someone has “exposure” to girls what does that mean exactly. Has he been flirting with girls a lot, has he become physical with girls etc…?
i agree with you 101% 🙁
Very sorry for the chilled guy, but he got the natural consequence of his actions. The Rebbe says very clearly: That when we are close when we are meant to be far, we will end up being far when we are meant to be close. The Torah guidelines which disapprove of casual pre-marital or extra-marital friendships are not to fence us in, but are for our very own benefit. We disregard the frum lifestyle at the peril of our very own happiness. So, chilled bochur, do tshuva and hopefully you will find in marriage the meaning and friendship that eluded… Read more »
Your comment was really difficult to read due to your poor english. Wow
Please tell me you are French or Spanish and English is not your first language, because that is atrocious!
No counter-statements except for one very urgently-needed and helpful outlook: People exist out there, who simply are not successful and/or comfortable with the traditional shidduch system. Perhaps “Chanoch LaNaar Al Pi Darko” does not refer exclusively to literal teaching. As a community, we need to be more understanding and flexible.
no offense but if your a “770 Bocher ” what are you doing online?
SO NOW A BOCHUR WHO WAS LOW ENOUGH TO STOOPED TO HIS MOST BASE TEMPTATIONS “PREVIOUS CONTACT WITH GIRLS” IS CALLED MERELY A “CHILLED GUY”?????
RL HOW DEAR THIS AUTHOR WHITE WASH SUCH CREEPS/PREDATORS WITH A BENINE TITLE “CHILLED”????!!
THEY (THESE CREEPS) HAVE TAKEN ADVANTAGE OF ,DEGRADED AND WOMANIZED SOO MANY LOVE-STARVED YIDDISHE DAUGHTERS! (SHMOOZING THEM) USING THEM AND INEVITABLY DUMPING THEM HIGH AND DRY LIKE CHEAP PIECES OF MEAT WORTH LESS THEN A PAID…. RL
CALL A SPADE A SPADE (AND A SELFISH CREEP A LOWLIFE THAT HE IS!!)
Wow, thanks collive this is so amazing and informative.
Please keep bringing us articles like these.
May there be many more mazel tovs to share!
Mom from CH
I am your average 770 bocher, considered a good bocher etc. from a good family and everythihg.
still I expect to be excited about my future wife, i am totally expecting it to be everything that i imagined and not a bit less.
i wont settle for what sounds good on paper.
Men should sweep you of your feet, Or so sais the ferrytale, When a man sais a woman did not sweep him of his feet ,he means mentaly, then he will continue literaly as in the ferrytale, after the wedding.!!!
Well done Mrs Junik, this is a well-constructed response!
You are good!!
Why are people bashing this guy???
I think he brought up an issue that others may have been wondering about themselves… I think it’s very mature of you to step up & voice your opinion (& don’t let anyone tell you otherwise!)
p.s I also liked how Mrs. Junik answered the question. She gave constructive tips, without putting anyone down!
though why did she advertise a website
and i liked comment 5 though i am great!
how do we deal in shidduchim if someone doesnt have a clear future and has options
and i am committed to live with the one i am dating i pray to g-d when i start to give it my all and to marry her
When my son was dating his wife he said that he really liked her but asked how he should know if she was the “right” one.
I advised him to date 100 more girls and compare them but he decided to stick with her. Keneinahora their kids are very cute!
Is Step #5 redundant to Step #4? or is step #5 geared towards the person looking for the shidduch him/herself vs. the parents? Is there an implied suggestion for the guy or girl to do his/her own research after the parents have presented him/her with a name?
am a chilled guy as u call it. bot as my past experience hanging out with girls and finding Ur own girl for a shidduch isnt the best thing.it didn’t work for me and i have frands which wher vary burnt from it , and they where vary serious ,and are still in pain. a sistom was made for us, it work t all this yrs,what has changed? it is vary hard wan u just get in to a relationship for awhile before u get engaged,than u have fights arguments and their isn’t anything holding on to u guys, so… Read more »
u sound like a freak and really lame, why do u expect that your gonna get miss perfect if ur not mr perfect
To the guy who wrote this question, instead of asking “nice girl, but why is she different than anyone else out there? What makes her the special one for me?”
Ask yourself “why am I different than anyone else out there? What makes me the special one for her, or any girl?”
In other words. whats in it for her?
You will be shocked by the answer!
thanks for this article!!!realy helped me with an idea for my 2nd son
I don’t agree with the terms used-770 bochur, chilled, frozen, LSS, and last but not least, Frum but with it bothers me the most
I think one of the main problems these days is that boys like the author of the letter expect to be “swept off their feet.” Hold on a second, aren’t the boys the ones that are supposed to do the sweeping???!!