Oct 8, 2017
The Wife Who Stole Her Husband
Illustration photo by Israel Bardugo

Stanford Shliach Dov Greenberg shares a love tale from the Midrash and a charming Chassidic story that can influence your marriage.

By Rabbi Dov Greenberg - Under The Chuppa Magazine

The Midrash recounts that in the second century, in the famous seaport town of Sidon, on the coast of Lebanon, there lived a married couple who were blessed with wealth and an honored position in the community. There was, however, a great void in their lives. Although married for ten years, they had no children. The couple decided to get divorced.

They turned to the great Rabbi Shimon Bar Yochai for advice. He looked at the couple for a long time, and then he said to them, I ask only one thing of you both: If you must part, then just as you wed with celebration, so should you part from each other with celebration."

They took his advice and arranged a great feast. During the evening, the husband raised his cup and said to his wife who was soon to leave, True, this is the last meal we shall share together, but dont leave just yet. Before you go, look around at the treasures of this house, choose ᒗ the most precious jewel your heart desires- and take it back with you to your parents house.

The wife did not respond to his offer. Instead, she mixed and spiced the wine and they drank a lot. The candles burned low in the room and the husband, overcome by a heavy drowsiness, fell asleep. While he was asleep, the wife told her servants to lift him up on the cushions upon which he slept and carry him to her parents house. As dawn broke, the husband opened his eyes in a daze and discovered that he was in unfamiliar surroundings.

Astonished, he asked, Where am I?

In the house of my parents, she said.

Why? he asked.

This is where you asked to be taken. Did you not say to me last night, Take with you the most precious thing your heart desires? To me, dear husband, there is nothing in the world more precious than you.

With inexpressible feelings, they embraced. They had found each other again. They now fully realized how strongly they loved each other.

The next day, the couple of Sidon appeared again before Rabbi Shimon Bar Yochai. He had expected them, and at a glance perceived their happy reunion and deep love. He prayed for the couple, and in time, after a joyful year, they were blessed with a child.

What is the message of this story? And why didnt Rabbi Shimon Bar Yochai pray for them in the first place?

The story of the couple of Sidon, says the Alter Rebbe, is not only about them; it tells an eternal truth about every marriage, and about the enduring power of love.

You see, when the couple first came to Bar Yochai, their love for each other was conditional, goal-oriented. If the marriage was not producing a child, there was ultimately no point to it. But then as they were about to part, they discovered how deeply they loved each other. They began to celebrate the intrinsic value of love.

So the couple went back to visit the rabbi, not because they had a solution, but because they knew they wanted to be together. And paradoxically, it was when the couple began to understand the purity of love that has no ulterior motive that their relationship bore fruit.Ster

So it is with us: when we love our spouse unconditionally, our lives are blessed. When we love selflessly, that is when the miracles begin to flow into our relationships.4 This is the great paradox at the heart of emotional life. When we worry only about ourselves, when we constantly think about how to make ourselves happier, we guarantee that our deepest needs will go unmet. But when we learn to give our love away unconditionally, we discover fulfillment and happiness.

Our society puts too much emphasis on being loved and not enough on being a loving person. The trouble with this focus is that none of us has the power to make others love us. But we all have the power to give away love to others. And if we do so, we change the kind of person we are, and the kind of world we live in.

A charming Chassidic story demonstrates this truth: Yankel was a simple Jew who loved the mitzvah of lulav and esrog, which he performed enthusiastically every Sukkot. He would spend hours painstakingly picking out the nicest esrog. One year, there was an early winter and it was difficult for the esrog salespeople to get their regular inventory, so there was a shortage and prices went up. Yankel was shocked when he heard that an esrog now cost 150 rubles. He went home saddened and told his wife the news. It was the day before Sukkot, and only one expensive esrog was left.

In Judaism, there is a concept called mitzvah of the moment, meaning that the mitzvah at hand now is supreme. So Yankel decided that for this holiday, the mitzvah of lulav and esrog was most important. Why dont I sell my tefillin, take the money I get from it and buy the esrog? I wont need the tefillin until after Sukkot. How I buy them back, well, Ill figure it out later.

So he sold his tefillin for 150 rubles and bought the esrog. He came home all excited, and, finding that his wife was not yet home, he carefully put the esrog down in the kitchen and went to take a nap. An hour later, he awoke to find that his wife had returned. Excitedly he called out, Guess what I bought?! An esrog!

How? she asked.

I sold my tefillin.

How could you do such a thing? she asked. He explained the mitzvah of the moment. Nu, let me see it, she said. Its right here, he replied, I put it down right here on the kitchen counter.

Oy vey! she shouted, I came home and made applesauce. I needed a lemon and saw what I thought was a lemon on the counter and diced it up and mixed it into the pot!

Cringing, Yankels wife expected a scream, an outcry. Instead, Yankel ran toward her, hugged her, and started dancing. Why, Yankele? she asked.

Because right now, my dear wife, the mitzvah of the moment is to love my wife and control my anger.

We all have the power to give away love to others. Yankel was not focused on himself. He was focused on loving his wife. He understood that Judaism is about getting us to rise above ourselves, to celebrate the mitzvah of the moment, which is always to love others, to love G-d, and to be there for them.

When we feel that our spouse is -the most precious thing in the world- when we learn to love and cherish our spouse even when they turn an esrog into applesauce, our lives are blessed and miracles can flow.


1 Shir HaShirim Rabba 1:31.
2 Maamarei Admor HaZaken HaKetzarim, pp. 460-462.
3 Not every marriage is blessed with biological children, there were many great Jews throughout history who were not blessed with children. Nevertheless, everyone can be blessed with spiritual children.

Most Read Most Comments

Opinions and Comments
yasher coach
(10/8/2017 6:10:28 PM)
Thank you,this is beautiful
(10/8/2017 7:57:57 PM)
interesting story
(10/8/2017 8:28:48 PM)
Great article
Great article - beautiful message
(10/8/2017 10:09:43 PM)
Thank you Dov Greenberg.
You hit it out of the park. Again.
(10/8/2017 10:31:54 PM)
beautiful message
If all energry was focused on keeping the peace at all cost,
maybe everything will fall into place.
Its a gamble worth taking. or maybe not who knows
(10/8/2017 10:44:22 PM)
Hashgacha pratis
I heard this story for the first time yesterday...
And then this article.
(10/8/2017 11:24:47 PM)
Beautiful story
Thank you for sharing. I enjoy hearing you speak, Rabbi Greenberg and I look forward to anything else you might share.
(10/9/2017 6:53:26 AM)
Wow- beautifully written .
(10/9/2017 9:35:12 AM)
This speaks to me it's very relevant to my life .
(10/9/2017 9:36:08 AM)
Thank you
Beautiful... thank you for bringing it home to us... *:-)
(10/9/2017 9:49:14 AM)
The chidush of chasidus
In vol beis of "OhrYisrael" Hebrew edition pg.pey gimel (Gal Einai publishing www.inner.org)there is a Baal Shemtov story with a similar theme...source is sefer hasichos tav shin gimel p.158
(10/9/2017 9:35:46 PM)
This really inspired me!
Thank you!
(10/10/2017 11:15:48 AM)
What's Your Opinion? Post a Comment

Your Comment:

Comments must be approved before being published. Thank You!

Make COLive your homepage | Contact Us
© 2018 COLLIVE.com