ב"ה
Tuesday, 2 Adar II, 5784
  |  March 12, 2024

Eruv Vandal Caught On Video

A vandal pulling down a controversial Brooklyn eruv was caught on surveillance video, as the actions are being investigated as a hate crime. Full Story

New Chesed Ambulette Vandalized

Next Story »

Greek Island Gets Own Chabad

Subscribe
Notify of
100 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
To #98
July 29, 2016 6:16 pm

“Some say it’s kosher” doesn’t make a difference. See Bava Metzia 66a, where Rav Nachman holds that a certain type of document is valid, whereas Rav Yehudah disagreed and tore it up.

Another example might be ibid. 59a, where the Chachamim who disagreed with R. Eliezer “burned all of the things that he had declared tahor” (although maybe that’s a special case, since in fact he was outvoted).

To 98
July 29, 2016 5:56 pm

And who gave you permission to go the the authorities regarding someone who may have pulled down some useless strings which some self rightness fools call an eruv

to 95
July 29, 2016 2:53 pm

are you comparing this guy to S. Munkes?
on what ground does he have a right to destroy a property (that some say is Kosher)?

All those who think they are holier than thou
July 29, 2016 4:54 am

Just remember that as a Jew you may not inform on another Jew.

to #80
July 29, 2016 3:23 am

I am #62, thank you very much for your support.

Just for the record, I am a “she”, not a “he”. 🙂

To 93
July 29, 2016 3:03 am

We’re not saying he had a right or didn’t have a right to break the eruv. Rather, that you cannot call him metzer harabim,and permit mesira unless we are sure he passeled a kosher eruv.
If not, one is at least risking behind a safek mossur. This is even worse than being a Mechalel shabbos.
According to you, did t Shmuel munkes have a right to throw out the delicious lung, which”he felt” wasn’t kosher.

An open letter to Rabbi Wosner
July 29, 2016 12:22 am

1.Rabbi Wosner, are you telling the people of another shachunah not to listen to all their rabbonim both present and past? could you please quote all the halachos and maforshim concerning not listining to your rabbonim. 2.Your own chavarim rabbonon of Monsey told you not to mix into to the rabbonim of Crown Heights. 3. Your father Rabbi Shamuel Wosner was an ish ha’shalom and would not tell people, not to listen to their rabbonon.. 4. I think you are wrong concerning the eruv of Lakewood . a) Some people have made small eruvin,not one that goes around the entire… Read more »

to 73
July 28, 2016 11:02 pm

“Since many are of the opinion that this is no eruv, how is he metzer harabim? He has rabbonim who say he did nothing, since there was no eruv anyway.”
even according your words “many” are the opinion so there are “some ” who say “is Kosher” eruv
on what right he has a heter to destroy somebody else property? if they serving at a simcha some food that”many rabbonim”don’t hold about the hecsher can i go and destroy it( the food ) or spoil the simcha??

Machti es harabim???
July 28, 2016 9:13 pm

– applies to those who put up the eruv,
Not those who took it down….
Those who put it up are giving ppl the false belief that there is a kosher eruv that they may carry in and causing them to b mechalel shabbos.
Those that take it down are trying to save ppl from this false hope.
Either way not allowed to carry here, at least if they hear the eruv is down they may decide not to.

To 73
July 28, 2016 6:07 pm

This is clear mesirah. Dince many are of the opinion that this is no eruv, how is he metzer harabim? He has rabbonim who say he did nothing, since there was no eruv anyway. Just as one who relyes on an eruv which is a machlokes cannot be called Mechalel shabbos. Crown heights is obviously different where there is no rav who publicly takes responsibility for the eruv and it’s as if is not there, as the psak of many rabbonim, so the one who uses it is Mechalel shabbos , and the one who informs on him is a… Read more »

Aveirah goireres aveirah
July 28, 2016 5:26 pm

First they go against the Rebbe, Rabonim and community by putting up an eruv, and they try to put yidden in jail…
Hashem yerachem, who are these eruv rav??

more to response to vosner
July 28, 2016 4:25 pm

I forgot many points, but for now I will mention three points (among many others). One: when the rebbe was asked by rabbi moscovitch for a haskomo to his work permitting an eruv in manhattan, the rebbe responded that he can’t for a number of reasons, one of which is: that he would have to go through the work thoroughly and he does not have time. Never the less, when the rebbe writes about using the Eruv for a regular frum jew, he says one should not use it in practice. He said this while not looking into it thoroughly,… Read more »

Even if criminals
July 28, 2016 2:53 pm

Yidden, who are we to ask for punishments and what gives? This is not the way of Torah. Had the eiruv people done things in the proper way, this would not have happened. Everyone here is mistaken and let’s not be self-righteous. It hurts our G-dly souls to be judges. let’s revamp our yiddishkeit each of us be more loving

they should be punished!
July 28, 2016 11:51 am

i am not for this eiruv but i still don’t believe this is right! i hope they catch these guys who are CRIMINALS! it doesn’t matter if you don’t believe in the eiruv..this is wrong.

modern orthodox....
July 28, 2016 11:07 am

is one step away from not frum….the kids either totally turn away once they catch on you can pick and choose…or if youre verrry lucky, theyll be baalei teshuva.
but dont beieve for a second that theyll remain ‘modern orthodox’ like you….

the chillul hashem is...
July 28, 2016 11:02 am

the eiruv itself!!!

shabbos kodesh is one of the main things that define a frum jew. if it was so simple……… an eiruv would be up years ago.

to #4 and #69
July 28, 2016 10:43 am

i definitely read that whole thing

Rabbis
July 28, 2016 9:56 am

This is the Halacha ” vandalized the eruv”
But. Ein morim ken
Very simple
Many ppl in Lubavitch would spiritual die if the physical eruv stays ( maybe not now , but in 10 years, little by little)
New generation hardly wear a hat ( only on Shabbos) no too much tzniut , things are going in the eruv use direction , means that Lubavitch is converting rl in modern orthodox little by little
Few ppl eat only Lub shechita , this is the direction of new generation. We have to eradicate the eruv. Sakanas nefashos

The Rebbe- Rosh Bnei Yisroel
July 28, 2016 9:41 am

The Rebbe is not just the head of Lubavitchers but a leader of world Jewery. Spend the day at the ohel or 770, look at the lines for dollars, all Jews sought out the Rebbe’s Holy advice. Why are we making distinctions between “types” of Jews and who needs to respect the Rebbe’s directives and who ch”v does not. Jews should respect the Rebbe’s directives, especially in the neighborhood known as the Rebbe’s neighborhood. Am Yisroel chai! Don’t dafka go creating machlokis out of convenience.

mendoza
July 28, 2016 8:55 am

i hope its not a yid who is breaking the eruv
cuz that would be even a biger chlul hashem

To 62
July 28, 2016 8:19 am

Please everyone, hear what he said, and take it to heart!

Bentzy Wosner Huchzak Shakran
July 28, 2016 8:13 am

He writes in his letter that both sides came to him, the pro-eruv to support them and the anti-eruv that he should protest. What utter nonsense! The anti-eruv people don’t need to seek out some second-rate meshuchad in another community! All of their local rabbonim concur with the psak of rov minyan ubinyan of the gedolei haposkim of the previous dor who ruled unequivocally that this eruv is 100% possul. Why would they need the intervention of Bentzy Wosner?!?

#59, the analogy is exact
July 28, 2016 8:10 am

“That is not a fair mushul and it doesn’t apply”

Actually it’s too mild. Cutting one person’s electric lines only harms that person. Vandalising a communal eruv destroys the whole community’s oneg shabbos, and causes chilul shabbos, and is thus מיצר את הרבים, and the Shulchon Oruch says one may masser him.

“Even in that case, you don’t use Goyim to punish Yiden, EVER ”

That’s your opinion; the Torah disagrees.

#46, "kulos"
July 28, 2016 7:49 am

1. What makes you think any kulos were needed for this eruv? Which “reputable poskim” would consider this eruv possul? As far as I know there aren’t any. The most any reputable posek might say is that it isn’t mehudar. And of course Lubavitchers shouldn’t use it because the Alter Rebbe wants us to be machmir like the Rambam. But to say that it’s possul?! Nobody who is expert in hilchos eruvin would agree to that. The opponents are the ones who are collecting wild and incompatible chumros from wherever they can find. Their posiiton is halachically untenable. 2. Even… Read more »

Yes, it's the rabbonim's fault
July 28, 2016 7:42 am

If they don’t publicly denounce the vandals, and call on anyone with information to tell the police, then they are responsible. This is the standard the Rebbe held the Satmar rabbonim to, and what’s good for the goose is good for the gander.

#27 "Hate does not make a diff"
July 28, 2016 7:39 am

“Hate does not make a diff if you are both from the same religion”

Hating people is not a crime, and crimes motivated by hatred on grounds other than those specified in the law are not “hate crimes”. This crime was not committed because the criminals hated someone’s religion; they believe in the exact same religion themselves (contrary to #15) , so how could they hate it? Therefore it’s not eligible for a sentence enhancement.

#26 "freedom of religion"
July 28, 2016 7:35 am

“As far as I know, every human has the inherent right to worship and participate in their faith as they see appropriate for them. ” The Torah says otherwise. Nobody has the right to defy Hashem, and idolaters deserve the death penalty. That’s not a popular position nowadays, since it’s directly contrary to the principles on which the USA was founded, but the Torah says the founders were wrong. Incidentally, one of the things a Jew has no right to believe is that there’s something wrong with making an eruv. מי שאינו מודה בתורת עירוב has the din of a… Read more »

#25 mesirah
July 28, 2016 7:32 am

” To report a Jew and get a Jew in trouble using Goyim, regardless of whether the Jew did something wrong or not, is the real crime ”

Wrong. Whoever damages a communal eruv is מיצר את הרבים, and it is permitted to masser him.

#15 is a liar
July 28, 2016 7:30 am

“The Frierdiker Rebbe paskened that the movement with that name is heretical”

That is a wicked lie, a slander against both the Frierdiker Rebbe and all the Modern Orthodox Jews who have lived in the past 150 years or so, including rabbonim, poskim, talmidei chachomim, whose shoes you are unfit to kiss. I call on whoever moderates these comments to delete that horrible claim.

Oy!
July 28, 2016 4:14 am

What is happening to us? Is this not madness?

3 Weeks
July 28, 2016 4:11 am

Come on guys….

No offence, but some of the comments on this article and on all previous ones showes u haven’t opened a Shulchan Aruch, Sefer Hamitzvos or anything else to see what is actually the case

response to vosner
July 28, 2016 3:14 am

I have recently seen the new letter from bentzion vosner.this author has recently had family circumstances which do not allow him too much time to put forth a professional piece, but in truth this shoddy letter from this individual does not deserve that much either. What I will try to do is the following, I will try to point out but a few points, which will show that this man while writing so sharp, has just no standing with which to write in the first place. There is a central theme that should be noted, there were many great talmidei… Read more »

why are ppl blaming the rabbonim for all this???
July 28, 2016 1:21 am

remember…. the rabbonim said NO to the eiruv, before it was known, several young ppl approached the rabbonim, and when they received no from every rov, they went ahead and found other sources out of crown heights, to get the eiruv up. the rabbonim are serving us, answering shailos at all times of day and night. shabbos, yom tov and weekday. my question is where are the ppl????

there is nothing to discuse!
July 28, 2016 12:55 am

1) when the rabbonim of this neighborhood of crown heights all Paskend – PE ECHOD – AGAINST the eiruv, so the eiruv is NOT A KOSHER EIRUV. And I am certain, that People That G-D, TOIROH & MITZVOIS, Mater To Them – So they Definatly will Not Carry on Shabboss. 2) in Connection With The Vandalism: The rabbonim Must Take A Stand – and can Not be Two faced, ( please forgive me for the expression), If the rabbonim Believe that AL PI TOIROH the eiruv Should Be vandalized, So Write The Psak Din ALL TOGETHER ON YOUR STATIONARY –… Read more »

The Rebbe- Rosh Bnei Yisroel
July 28, 2016 12:49 am

The Rebbe is not just the head of Lubavitchers but a leader of world Jewery. Spend the day at the ohel or 770, look at the lines for dollars, all Jews sought out the Rebbe’s Holy advice. Why are we making distinctions between “types” of Jews and who needs to respect the Rebbe’s directives and who ch”v does not. Jews should respect the Rebbe’s directives, especially in the neighborhood known as the Rebbe’s neighborhood. Am Yisroel chai! Don’t dafka go creating machlokis out of convenience.

so whats news?
July 27, 2016 11:59 pm

Aguc”h has not been able to hold a function in 770 for over 21 years because they will be beaten up. And they were the people appointed by the rebbe in legal documents to own the property. How long did you expect the eruv to last? I can not fathom the outrage. What planet have you been living on? The rabbonim should have simply said “The eruv is like OU-D, Kosher, and we do not eat it” You could spend money each week fixing the eruv, and at 4am Friday morning the drunk warriors will gird their loins to defend… Read more »

To #20
July 27, 2016 11:52 pm

The crime is going against the Rebbe’s ratzon that there should be no Eruv

To #55
I’m sure you meant that פינחס is the one that took it down

Pinchas
July 27, 2016 11:51 pm

For all those comparing this to Pinchas:
You’re equating someone who was doing zenus befarhesya with putting up an eiruv? Have you lost your mind? No one said you have to hold by the eiruv — don’t! But don’t be machtee es harabim!

Where did the Rebbe ever say it's kosher to malign other Jews?
July 27, 2016 11:07 pm

The Baal Shem Tov said the way you can tell if someone loves the Oibershter is whether he loves the Oibershter’s children, i.e. other Jews. This was not limited to Jews of one’s own shita. The Barditchever famously always looked for excuses for Jews who weren’t shomer mitzvos. The Rebbe never, ever spoke bad about other Jews, or as far as I remember, even about goyim! To say the eruv is not kosher and present the halachic reasoning as to why not, is no problem. Not to use the eruv is no problem. To speak bad about the people who… Read more »

PEOPLE ENOUGH!!!
July 27, 2016 11:06 pm

YOU WANT TO MAKE AN EIRUV? MAKE IT. YOU WANT TO TEAR IT DOWN? TEAR IT DOWN.

MIX THE REBBE OUT OF IT!!!!

ALL OF SUDDEN WE KNOW WHAT THE REBBE SAID, WHAT THE REBBE WILL SAY, WHAT THE REBBE THINKS ETC

YEVSEKTSIYA
July 27, 2016 11:00 pm

History repeating itself!

To #44
July 27, 2016 10:37 pm

That is not a fair mushul and it doesn’t apply

Even in that case, you don’t use Goyim to punish Yiden, EVER

#15
July 27, 2016 10:32 pm

Here you have shluchim going out to make people frum, and then they go out to try to destroy an eruv that had nothing to do with Chabad, and conservative and Reform would not care about an eruv they would carry with out one, and who made you in charge of Crown Heights, there are other people that live here not just chabad. And I hope they catch the people that vandalized the eruv,

To #4
July 27, 2016 10:25 pm

Who has the time and patience to read your very very very long Drosha?

Now for sure can't use it
July 27, 2016 10:25 pm

First of all, there is no eiruv.
Second of all, even if there is an opinion that it is a valid eiruv, since it was vandalized 3 times, it has now a חזקה that it is tampered.

Eruv was built by
July 27, 2016 10:20 pm

פינחס בן אלעזר בן אהרון הכהן
The real tzadikim of our time… they are mezake the community at large

Do u really think k that congregation kol yisrael..
July 27, 2016 10:07 pm

Would force their eiruv on crown heights?! There are “crown heights trouble makers who organized this anonymously on kol Israels name!!

Well timed
July 27, 2016 10:07 pm

I know who it was…
פינחס בן אלעזר בן אהרון הכהן

By putting up the eiruv...
July 27, 2016 10:03 pm

It is causing much controversy to the extent of seeking the arrest of JEWS on a hate crime!!! It is ‘liberal’ Jews who put the alter rebbe and friedeker rebbe in jail…… Where r theybwhat has become of them! Ooooh to those who put up the eoruv!

To #11
July 27, 2016 9:39 pm

100%! First of all, it is very far from where many Lubavitchers live, and second of all, if people want to put it up, we DO NOT have to use it! I agree that if the Rebbe didn’t allow it, than OF COURSE we should NOT use it, no doubt about it, but, as a question, NOT a statement, do we have the right to tell people not to put it up? Also, it was definitely wrong of these people to vandalize it! Another thing, if the Rebbe said that we should not put it up, it was NOT his… Read more »

natan wildow
July 27, 2016 9:30 pm

I believe in seder in lubavitch which means no eruv against the rebbe
As zalman plotkah says lo eechpat Lee in eruv

this weeks parsha is parshas pinchas
July 27, 2016 9:20 pm

pinchas did the same he acted when action was needed kol hakovod to whoever ripped down the non-eruv it is a stumbling block before the blind and must be torn down shame on those that went to the police but i understand them they have their own interp on halacha going to the police in this case is the same kosher as their eruv most prob they got a long letter from mr wosner that it is ok in summary this place has rabbonim that are respected about 3500 families voted for them not to long ago and those that… Read more »

Sickening..
July 27, 2016 9:06 pm

Eruv ppl….do you really have lubavitch blood?? To wage war against all that is dear to our religion-? Against shabbos? Against putting fellow Jews in trouble? Where is your passion when ppl get mugged? It’s really all about you and what your yetzer hara wants….I truly hope those that are behind this case back down and do teshuva. Sometimes respecting the place you live, and it’s values should b more imp to u than doing what u want. The pain you are causing to the Rebbe, Hashem, the community etc….it’s appalling how you just don’t care. Give it up. Not… Read more »

#15
July 27, 2016 8:46 pm

Sir, what exactly is wrong with you? I would LOVE to debate you abut what exactly is wrong with Modern Orthodox and why it is akin to irreligious movements you mention. Yes, Rabbi Soloveitchik and Mordechai Kaplan, the founder of the Reconstructionist movement, really have a lot in common as far as their beliefs go. The fact is that there are many different levels of ‘Modern Orthodox’, including some who are more Yiras Shamayim than we may be. So lets love these folks for who they are….G-d fearing, Torah-loving Jews, out to make a difference in the world just like… Read more »

RABBI WOSNER TOTALLY MISSES THE POINT
July 27, 2016 8:30 pm

IN HIS LENGTHY ARTICLE (post #4) FILLED WITH THREATS AND CURSES TO THOSE WHO DO NOT BELIEVE IN THE CONCEPT OF EIRUV, HE TOTALLY MISSES THE POINT. NO ONE IS CHAS VESHOLOM AGAINST THE CONCEPT OF AN EIRUV. BUT AN EIRUV MUST BE MADE ACCORDING TO HALACHA. RABBI WOSNER KNOWS HOW MANY KULOS (leniences) HE HAS TO USE TO MAKE THIS EIRUV. THIS MEANS THAT ACCORDING TO MANY REPUTABLE POSKIM THE EIRUV IS INVALID, AND ONE WHO CARRIES IS MECHALEL SHABBOS CHAS VESHOLOM. LET HIM DISCLOSE ALL THE KULOS HE USED. ONCE WE START DOING MITZVOS BASED ON ALL THE… Read more »

to #5
July 27, 2016 8:24 pm

You need help!!
bcs i don’t keep you hidurim I have to move out
ever heard of AHAVAS YISROEL?
SEE Likutei Sichot vol.5 page.148.

to #25
July 27, 2016 8:15 pm

what if some vandals (or better called them terrorist) would come REPEATEDLY and cut your electric and gas line bcs you don’t keep HIS Hidurim would you say is a sin to report him????!!

angel
July 27, 2016 7:50 pm

an angel diid it
he is not going to be caught
do you know why?
because he is not a human being, he is an angel
a messenger from G-d
it is impossible an eruv in CH
No metzius

you gave a hechsher!!
July 27, 2016 7:30 pm

by breaking the eiruv, you are “indirectly” giving a hechsher!!
because, if it’s worthless, then why break it???!@!!@

Rabbi Wosner
July 27, 2016 7:27 pm

With respect…. well constructed…. HOWEVER the Rebbe (& Reb Moshe) said NO…..Also, calling the opposition all kind of names such as “Sitra Achera”, “false prophet”, “Kofer” and other such doozies is also not the acceptable Torah way.

Really?
July 27, 2016 7:26 pm

No more old people? They are our role models, our mentors! Without them, where would we be?!?!?!?

Blah. Blah blah here we go again
July 27, 2016 7:24 pm

Really? Now it’s all the rabbonim’s fault and they should step down? Do you know anything about anything?!!!?!? I have personally seen countless times how the rabbonim of crown heights LIVE for the community! Answering sheilos 24/7, during shabbos meals, late at night….. They are always there! I cannot believe it has come to a point to where people speak so degradingly about our leaders, our lights in galus! The rebbe’s messengers! Shame on you. Shame on you and on all the people who blame our devoted rabbonim for this, who blame them for saying their psak din! Which was… Read more »

i'm confused
July 27, 2016 7:10 pm

It says this took place by the Brooklyn Museum. What does that have to do with the Rebbe’s Daled Amos?

Seriously?
July 27, 2016 7:08 pm

@27: who needs help?
you hope he gets 10 years in jail?!?!?!?!?? And someone else wanted deportation?!?!? What’s the matter with you???!?!? I’m not pro or anti the Eruv, but these are YOUR FELLOW JEWS!!

You don't like it don't use it
July 27, 2016 6:59 pm

It’s embarrassing. I don’t think the Rebbe would tell you to go cut their eruv. You don’t have to accept it, but let them be. After r are chabad and stop bad mouthing and pushing away fellow yidden.

argentina bochuim
July 27, 2016 6:56 pm

According to reb zalman plotkah and harav natan wildow the eruv is totally against the rebbes will but whatever iif people want it up they should know that they are going against the rebbe and his will……
And also harav natan said it’s seder now meaning that this is causing bochurim to waste time but harav plotkah says “lo eechpat lee” do wtvr u want
What you do is against the rebbe

Obviously Not Chabad Chasidim
July 27, 2016 6:50 pm

It’s obviously not Chabad Chasidim if it happened 8 am on a Sunday, which is before Chabad Chasidim even wake up.

We are in the 3 weeks
July 27, 2016 6:48 pm

I beg of you to desist of any controversies, this is not the best time .
I am sure The Rebbe doesnt need this, we wants unity for all.
Lubavitchers should adhere to our traditions and may we insire with love others , this creates the opposite effect.
Lets fix ourselves and may we merit the coming of Moschiach

where is the video?
July 27, 2016 6:45 pm

what u show is a still pic not showing anything at all

Over discussed subject..
July 27, 2016 6:44 pm

The Eiruv has caused so many arguments with no conclusions.. I wish it was possible to just forget about it, yes Eiruv no Eiruv.. If you’re a chossid of the Rebbe don’t use it and forget that it does or doesn’t exist..

the rebbe said
July 27, 2016 6:40 pm

Rabbi wisner,sorry with all due respect to you, I respect the lubavitcher rebbe a lot more!besides this our neighborhood! !!!

Rabbinim need to do something
July 27, 2016 6:37 pm

If rabbinim don’t come out against the vandals this will continue and you’ll see a lot of copy cat vandals thinking they are in the right. Regardless in your stance of the Eiruv, GD forbid a Jew go to jail over this. Rabbinim speak up and control the situation now before a chillul Hashem is made on a national level or worse a Jew faces hate crime charges! You lost on the Eiruv for keeping silent all these years when the community really needed leadership. Now you could still stop this from getting any worse than it has already has… Read more »

Crazy!!!
July 27, 2016 6:36 pm

You can get assaulted\robed\mugged and the cops dont even bother looking for the guy despite crown height being full on cameras (ask anyone living here) and now they come running crazy!

To 15#
July 27, 2016 6:33 pm

U need help

And I hope they find the guy and we know it is and he gets charged with a HATE CRIME with is close to 10 years in JAIL THIS IS NO JOKe. CHABAD is not a terror organization and these guys need they faces hanged all over CH whoever did this and let them sit a months and they will learn a lesson.

To 24#

Hate does not make a diff if you are both from the same religion

To #15
July 27, 2016 6:25 pm

As far as I know, every human has the inherent right to worship and participate in their faith as they see appropriate for them. One size does not fit all. Lubavitch does not “own” Crown Heights, any more than does any group. I do not understand why those who want to use it, use it; and those who do not want to use it, don’t use it. Not everyone believes the same about an erev, obviously. Isn’t that normal? Isn’t it the way of the world that differences exist? Is not Crown Heights part of the world? Ergo………

The Real Crime
July 27, 2016 6:12 pm

To report a Jew and get a Jew in trouble using Goyim, regardless of whether the Jew did something wrong or not, is the real crime

Hate crime?!
July 27, 2016 5:28 pm

I don’t see how this could be a hate crime. It clearly wasn’t motivated by hatred for anyone’s religion. The vandals and the eruv makers have the same religion, and there is no hatred between them. The vandals’ motivation was to protect their turf, to project their authority, to enforce their preferences, much like any gang does. It’s reprehensible, it’s a crime, but not a “hate crime”. They should be caught and punished, but no sentence enhancement is called for.

Rabbi Wosner
July 27, 2016 5:22 pm

1. He has clearly not seen any of the Rebbe’s letters expressing his reasons for opposing public eruvin in large cities.

2. Shlomo Hamelech didn’t make things easier, he made things harder. Before him there was no such thing as eruv chatzeros, because you could carry in any chatzer. He was the one who forbade carrying in a reshus hayochid with multiple owners unless you make an eruv.

HATE CRIME
July 27, 2016 5:21 pm

The real hate crime here is causing maclokes in the community by building an Eruv and hiding behind another shul to avoid taking the blame.

I hope the Eruv comes down, and soon, so we can go back to enjoying peaceful Shabbosim together without the pressure of seeing people carrying.

#4 ENOUGH
July 27, 2016 5:20 pm

You are not a Rav Poisek in Crown Heights besides all
the other facts….. So don’t mix in where OUR Rabbonim
in the name of OUR HOLY REBBE strongly disapprove
of an eiruv!!!

#2 where's the crime?
July 27, 2016 5:18 pm

Putting up the eruv was not a crime at all, so how can it be a hate crime?

These eruv ppl.....
July 27, 2016 5:10 pm

Just love machlokes….in any way, shape or form…its a selfishness that stops at nothing….

Oy nebach
July 27, 2016 5:10 pm

Good. Those criminals will get punished. This disgusting behavior is what tarnishes the chabad name. The Rebbe may not have wanted the eruv but there is no way he would have allowed destroying it.

The poster says "we want Mashiach now"
July 27, 2016 4:59 pm

When Mashiach comes, will he be allowed to put up an eruv?

To number 3
July 27, 2016 4:53 pm

Just finished reading your post…. NOT

Modern Orthodox isn't Orthodox
July 27, 2016 4:52 pm

The Frierdiker Rebbe paskened that the movement with that name is heretical. It has no more standing halachically than reform, conservative, reconstructionist, christianity, sabatai tzvi-ism or frankist.

Leave it
July 27, 2016 4:41 pm

And talk to Your mashpia about what you should do.

Chillul Lubavitch!
July 27, 2016 4:38 pm

Thank GD!!

Rabbi Wosner
July 27, 2016 4:25 pm

I’ll take fries with that, please.

What is wrong with all of you?!
July 27, 2016 4:21 pm

You do not own the neighborhood! Other Jews live here too, and they have every right to put up an eruv. You don’t wnat to use it? don’t. but you have no right to destroy it.

Catch em
July 27, 2016 4:14 pm

I hope they catch them soon and make them pay at least double the expenses they caused. Perhaps some jail time, and deportation if applicable, is in order.

To M. Machlokes #5
July 27, 2016 4:12 pm

1) You are the one making Machlokes, just let them be.

2) You show how you really have no clue at all when you try to blame this on Chevrah Ahavas Yisroel. The Eruv was made by an actual modern orthodox Shul called Congregation Israel. Maybe there are individuals in Chevrah who like the Eruv as I am sure there are some in your shul who would like there to be an eruv too. They may have also reported on some true facts about the eruv rather than spread false messages but they certainly did not build it.

Yitzchok M
July 27, 2016 3:57 pm

What would the Rebbe do, tear it down, or tell his people to ignore it and follow his rulings? Probably also to love modern orthodox Jews who are most importantly Jews.

Sinas Chinam
July 27, 2016 3:31 pm

Yes, it is a hate crime called sinas chinam. A baseless hatred crime.

they should be locked up
July 27, 2016 3:14 pm

they went against the Rebbe…
their is 10,000 jews that the rebbe called the fifth son.. that are being saved from being mechalel shabbos

to say the rebbe was against the eruv is ludicrous!!!

Machlokes
July 27, 2016 3:11 pm

This eiruv is causing so much controversy and fighting. Chevras ahavas yisrael, y don’t u live up to ur name, and forgo the eiruv even though u really want it.

For those of u who consider a urselves modern orthdox, y don’t u move to one of the many modern orthodox neighborhoods in the country!

Rabbi Wosner
July 27, 2016 3:11 pm

בן ציון יעקב הלוי ואזנר אב”ד דבד”ץ ובית הוראה שבט הלוי מאנסי – בית שמש Rabbi Benzion Y. Wosner Rosh Beis Din Shevet Halevi Monsey – Beit Shemesh בעזהי”ת ט”ז תמוז ה’ לס’ “הנני נותן לו את בריתי שלום” תשע”ו שלו’ ורב ישע אל מע”כ ידידינו היקרים הרבנים הגאונים והיק’ שליט”א עסקני וכלל תושבי קראון הייטס ה’ עליהם יחיו בענין העירוב שהוקם לאחרונה בשכונתכם “קראון הייטס” שנבנה ע”י בית דין חשוב ונבדק ע”י הרה”ג דוד אהרן צובלי שליט“א, עם שאר רבנים, והציבור מפולג, חלק מבקשים ושמחים בעירוב כנהוג, והציבור מפולג, חלק מבקשים ושמחים בעירוב כנהוג, וחלק מתנגדים מטעמים שונים ומשונים,… Read more »

Boruch Hashem
July 27, 2016 3:09 pm

I hope they catch them… they got video

Ridiculous
July 27, 2016 3:06 pm

That’s ridiculous. Putting up the so called “Eiruv” was the hate crime.

Always trying to get back at the Jews
July 27, 2016 3:00 pm

No where else will you see this. Ridiculous. They need to show that they are not ‘biased against the blacks’ because they are so frightened, that they will make a mountain out of a molehill if it concerns ‘the Jews’.

X