By Eliyahu Federman, Jerusalem Post
President Barack Obama had no reservations attempting to block the execution of Humberto Leal Garcia, a Mexican man that was convicted in 1994 of the rape and murder of a 16-yearold girl in San Antonio. On July 5, 2011, The Guardian reported that: “The White House has asked the US Supreme Court to put the execution of Humberto Leal Garcia on hold while Congress passes a law that would prevent the convicted rapist and murderer from being put to death along with dozens of other foreign nationals who were denied proper access to diplomatic representation before trials for capital crimes.”
Of course we all also remember the president’s public comments regarding allegations of police misconduct in the arrest of Henry Louis Gates on July 16, 2009.
In that case Obama seized the opportunity to point out that “[r]ace is still a troubling aspect of our society” and implored all Americans to calmly ponder ways to improve race relations “between police officers and minority communities.”
While Obama did not intervene in the local matter, he did use the moment to reflect on wider concerns of addressing police-community relations.
COMPARE THAT to the president’s silence regarding the case of Sholom Mordechai Rubashkin, who was convicted of bank fraud and sentenced by District Court Judge Linda Rae Reade to 27 years in prison for his mishandling of a revolving loan from First Bank Business Capital of St. Louis, as well as other loans.
Aside from the fact that Judge Reade’s extrajudicial ex-parte secret meetings with the prosecution were wholly inappropriate and undermined the fairness of the trial, a sentence of 27 years should be reserved for the most hardened criminals in our society, not a first-time, nonviolent offense. The ACLU, the Washington Legal Foundation and the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers filed supporting briefs in the appeal.
District and appellate courts have repeatedly imposed and approved single digit sentences in higher-dollar-loss white-collar cases.
But the White House has not reacted to those appeals.
A White House petition documented that over 75 law professors, including three former deputy attorneysgeneral, and 47 members of the House of Representatives separately and independently wrote to Attorney General Eric Holder calling for an investigation into prosecutorial misconduct surrounding Rubashkin’s disproportionate sentence.
A staggering 52,226 signed that petition – the president promised he would respond to any petition garnering 5,000 signatures – but Obama has yet to reply to the specifics of Rubashkin’s case or even address the broader policy concerns surrounding sentencing disparities.
The Obama administration said only that “[w]ith respect to law enforcement matters, the Department of Justice is charged with investigating crime and enforcing our laws” and that there are already “mechanisms in place to investigate allegations of prosecutorial misconduct.”
Sentencing disparities are well documented in our criminal justice system. A substantive response addressing the merits of Rubashkin’s claims may not be expected, but the Obama administration’s deafening silence failed to even acknowledge the bigger policy issue surrounding sentencing disparities in cases of prosecutorial misconduct.
In this particular case a Jewish man received a punishment that does not fit the crime, but a majority of unfair sentences in the United States are handed down to black people, Hispanics and members of other minority groups. It’s shameful and insensitive that Obama would not even take the time to acknowledge sentencing disparities in our system, even if he reserved comment on the merits of this particular case due to understandable separation of power concerns.
Obama was quick to attempt to prevent an execution of a man convicted of the rape and murder of an innocent 16-year-old girl and comment on a local police incident that he believed had racial undertones. In the first three years of his presidency he has granted clemency 17 times, including for several drug-related convictions. In light of those examples, his silence in the case of a nonviolent first-time offender with widespread public support speaks volumes.
Today, we can only hope the Supreme Court grants certiorari, or even for the less-likely scenario of a presidential pardon for Rubashkin.
We can only hope and pray for one of these remedies to remove this stain of injustice.
The writer is a graduate of the City University of New York School of Law, where he served as an executive editor of the law review. He has advocated for gender equality in voting rights, sexual abuse awareness and better police-community relations in Crown Heights.
We should make a new petition and get 52,000 signatures that states the following.
All 52,000 of the undersigned will vote against President Obama in next year’s election if the White House does not examine this case.
This will get their attention.
pardon of a president
The french president is next to obama
Your last line is absolutely wrong. It is a cruel lie and defamatory! Really, I’m disgusted by your ignorant and baseless statement.
Do you think Nat Lewin has a shortage of business? Do you know that he is actually doing this at a much lower rate than he charges other clients?! Nat has thrown his heart and soul into this and you besmirch him in such a way. Disgusting.
Please be careful with your words in the future. Thank you.
You will get 100 people who will go out for lunch and never return nobody will protest !!!!!! # 2 might be right….. I heard Nat Lewin the night he lost on Zeev Brenner and he was asked if he will appeal to the full Appellate court and not just the 3 which he lost. He answered that he will not since the 3 best and most lenient Judges were the ones who ruled on this already and he lost that there was no reason to bring it in front of the full court. Now that he has he knows… Read more »
We need a massive protest like the occupy wall street – Camp out by the white house and refuse to leave until Obama addresses the issue. It needs to be in the media attention – Yeshivas should sponsor buses for buchrim to attend. Our best Rabbis should speak. Stand together for Sholom!
yiddin are such staunch republicans these days, why should obama help?
Did the Rebbe give up on Russia when he said not to make public demonstrations against Russia and the USA ?? Do not agitate the US and the Courts because it will keep him locked up like Jonathan Pollard!!!!! #2 I think did not mean to say do nothing he meant I hope to do a lot of low key !!!!! There are many ways to get a pardon and a reduction of a sentence but when these things are done they must be accomplished quietly. to # 15 Yaguti ….. does not mean make a tumel and fight and… Read more »
start another petition with more specific guidelines, maybe that he conduct an investigation on judge reade.
Only public exhibits of outcry will help Sholom. Talking won’t do a thing. Demonstration on the mall. And efforts of the like will free reb Sholom M. That is the only way it will become an issue of public interest (not just a Jewish interest).
That is how Gilad Shalit was freed and the like.
Maybe we can make a silent demostration like if everyone leaves thier homes for certain time?Just to show our dissappointment as a community..
Sure, you sound like a “friend”, one who knows in advance that he will lose his appeal, one who apparently implies that they should have never appealed… A friend?
Telling them that “Wake up all avenues have been lost.” That’s a friend?
Number 2- the only one that can help is Obama????????????????????????? Its Hashem
Eli I only met you once but kol hakavod this is the type of battles u should be fighting great article when u running for congress
well done. interesting perspective. its about a universal issue not just Rubashkin…
more power to him!!!
politicians care about public sentiment
You couldn’t have been more wrong…
I don’t know if u have ever heard of the Posuk: “Yagati Umatzati Taamin”… Rubashkins keep on fighting! We are all with you in these troubling times.
Moshiach Now!
and a speedy Yeshua to Sholom Mordechai Halevi Ben Rivka
Pray tell, how is keeping low key going to help? Laying low will only push Obama to believe they have given up, and they haven’t. We have to persevere and Sholom Rubashkin will be home with his family.
A friend of his daughter.
Dont know how you can talk that way to a family thats going through so much! The Rubashkins perseverance and Bitochon is amazing and they should continue in their fight for justice! Maybe you gave up hope sadly but everyone else definitely didnt. We must cry out about this grave injustice because it really affects us all and we must get the media involved! We can not remain silent any longer! All the facts in this case just scream out blatant anti semitism in the 21st century. We all stand behind them and support them and may we see NOW… Read more »
maybe if no yid will vote for Obama over this, her will wake up and smell the coffee!
Obama’s forte is his mouth.
He talks well but he doesn’t walk well. That’s why the American people voted for him. I just can’t believe that anyone would consider him as suitable to continue with his presidency.
But, the American people don’t learn from their mistakes.
They will vote for him again. Such stupidity.
you are absolutely wrong!!!
rubashkin family and supporters keep fighting and makeing alot of noise!!! dont let the word guilty weaken you!!
look how the shalit family kept fighting and never gave up &
the impossible happened bh!!!
we are jewish , we believe in miracles, weve seen miracles and iyh we will see SM free , but we have to continue screaming for justice until we are heard!!!!!
#2 I am appalled by your comment. When you or your father or brother are heaven forbid sentenced to 27 years in prison then we’ll all keep quiet.
Rubashkins, keep fighting, we are all here with you. Perseverance is how the Jewish nation has survived until now and how you will save Sholom Mordechai.
A true family friend
sorry # 2…ure no friend.
Gilad SHalits parents did NOT give up and they got their kid back….
The shalit story as a whole is not relevant in this case as to wether we agree with the decision or not….but seriously dont tell someone to give up.
And to do it over a comment….thats cheap
not nice . he whants us to vote for him for the next year get out of here
Obama promised that he would see it. the problem is he takes $$$$ from the union & the union wants him to be against rubashkin. do u remember that on his campaigntrail he was already speaking against rubashkin without knowing anything!!!!
What is the point of these petitions anyway?! If the White House replies that “they don’t mix in” – so why in the world, do they fool the public by giving them a chance to petition in the first place?! What’s the point? A political gimmick?
more articles should be written about this ,bring this “no comment” story to the press ! people should know something is not right .
BS”D what so surprising-in our society a white victim is not a victim of racism
It is time to keep quiet and not make this a massive media blitz Lay low and try for a Pardon in a year… It is all that is left. The more you push this it will backfire…. If you keep the case low key and quiet then things might happen… The case was tried and he was guilty and then appealed and found guilty and now re-appealed and will be found Guilty… How many more time do you you need to hear the word Guilty. The only man who can help in the near term is Obama. The more… Read more »
Thing is, Obama probably doesn’t actually see the petitions… someone on his staff deals with it… He is probably only vaguely aware of the site… So, the comparison doesn’t work..